Brazilian Justice, a very Injustice system!
I am no lawyer or Judge, but I truly believe
that JUSTICE is a fundamental right that can be easily explain and be part of
everyone's daily life if common sense is applied. So what, in my
opinion, are the fundamental aspects that a JUSTICE system must have in order
to be an effective part of a society?
The first and most important is
the absence of impunity! If you commit a crime you must pay
for it! The punishment must fit the crime! These are quite obvious,
so Does Brazil have it? Let me give you some recent examples and you
take your conclusions:
In Brazil, juvenile criminals (Brazilian Law says
that under 18 years of age are consider "children" and
a special set of laws applied to them!) are on the rise! Adult’s career
criminals use these “children” to commit crimes on their behalf and benefit
from it! A juvenile criminal cannot be convicted to a normal imprisonment term
in a public jail. He will get no more than the time to reach his adulthood. So
you he/she is 17 years and 11 months old and kills someone, he will spend no
more than a month on a juvenile facility for the crime committed! Sure a judge
can see the absurd of it! There are legal mechanisms to impose a harder
punishment, but for a Judge is easier not to do so and let it get out of his
court! So impunity and no punishment that fits the crime is ever applied to
these "children”.
Brazilian
Justice System has a unique mathematical calculus system! You will not be impersonated
for more than 30 years regardless of your crime! If you have “good antecedents”,
“good behavior” and other strange legal terms, you time in jail will be cut to
1/6 of your full term! So if you kill someone for the “first” time, you may be
out in just 6 years! Again, a Judge has legal mechanisms to impose a harder
punishment and let you stay in the jail for much longer, but for a Judge is easier not to do so
and let it get out of his court!
In Brazil
murders by fire arms in 2013 were 35.000!! Car “accidents” killed another
54.000 Brazilians!! Accordingly to the “It was no accident” organization site (http://naofoiacidente.org/blog/como-assim-agora-apenas-8-o-numero-de-pessoas-condenadas-e-presas-por-crime-de-transito-no-brasil/)
just 8 Brazilians were convicted for a driving car accident resulting in
someone’s death! 54.000 deaths happed and just 8 convictions in 2013! IMPUNITY
RULES! Car accidents in Brazil are in most cases done by middle and upper
middle classes criminals! So the Justice System clearly favors those criminals!
Fire arms crimes convictions in Brazil is less than 8%! (http://g1.globo.com/jornal-da-globo/noticia/2014/04/maioria-dos-crimes-no-brasil-nao-chega-ser-solucionada-pela-policia.html).
We have more than a war zone death tool and a conviction of less than 8%,
IMPUNITY RULES!
These patterns
of Injustice are widely spread in Brazilian society! Brazilian society has this
strange behavior of complaining but no acting! So I think the picture is clear!
Crimes pay off in Brazil! Again in a normal situation, we would expect that Society
acts to correct such IMPUNITY, but you have to understand Brazilian society
(and any other underdeveloped country) to understand why is does not happen!
Lowers classes in Brazil (about 65-75% of the population) are educated in the public
education system, which I have comment on a previous text on this blog. This
education system is set up to keep the status quo! So they don’t know yet how
to make the changes and enforce it on our Legal and Law Systems! Education and
Elections takes time!
Judges in Brazil
are not afraid of any of his actions and when caught on a crime, normally
he/she gets an early retirement! IMPUNITY RULES!!
The upper
classes in Brazil use to have no interest on JUSTICE FOR ALL! Simply because
they are the criminals that most profit from not having a JUSTICE System
working and punishing! But like everything else if life, the bill is presented!
This bill is being presented in the most savage and ruffles ways! CRIMES are
getting into their homes! I mean it for real! In Brazilian Cities, criminals
are getting into your home when you are in it! Murders, car accidents, death is
on the rise! Surely the numbers are proportional to the population classes, but
at these levels, crimes to middle and upper classes reached staggering numbers! Citizens of these social classes that assumed they were immune to crimes are finally seeing that they are not! These staggering numbers, I hope, will finally make us to see and understand that JUSTICE
FOR ALL is the only way!
If you have
IMPUNITY, no Legal System is present and savage takes over! I can only hope and
do my part to show my friends in the middle and upper classes that JUSTICE FOR
ALL AND THE END OF IMPUNITY is the only way to a better future for ALL!!!
My next post
will be why I love Brazil so much!
All the best,